The RS leather-trimmed wheel is nicer to hold than the hard, wood-rimmed Nardi in the Aston, and we can forgive the chocolate-brown vinyl interior trim edging the very ’80s orange-check cloth seat inserts because, John says, it was the only colour available in 1980.
Outside, the large, flat-sided extra wheelarch panels are so straight and ripple-free that you wouldn’t believe they are glassfibre, and they are not just slip-over parts.
No doubt with heart in mouth, your friendly RS dealer would cut most of the bottoms out of the wings before grafting on the new panels, though John’s car benefits from having them properly bonded and matted on before painting, rather than riveted, by glassfibre/paint specialist Option 1.
The Aston Martin V8 Vantage X-Pack’s flared arches
As with the Aston, the complex carburetion doesn’t hamper starting, cold or hot (Ferrari owners take note), and there’s an instant Essex rumble, enhanced by a Janspeed exhaust.
Well, it would have been rude not to… John’s car now has a 3.4-litre Ric Wood engine, but it’s been detuned from 205bhp closer to the 175bhp of an original X-Pack.
It’s smooth, unlike an Essex in its raw state, and spins quite happily, needing 3000rpm for 70mph – although, being a ‘six’, it sounds busier than it is and is past its best by 5500rpm.
John has resisted the usual ‘upgrade’ to the much heavier Type 9 five-speed ’box as used in the later 2.8i (and lots of other Fords, from Sierra to Transit), and the change is both light and accurate in the close, four-speed gate.
The Aston Martin’s ducktail spoiler indicates this is something special
The steering, powered as standard on the 3.0S, is lighter and sharper, and the car turns in more eagerly, with less roll than the Aston.
Control inputs can be not quite so deliberate; it’s a car you can drive with less muscle, yielding more immediate changes of direction.
It gives away 200bhp to the Vantage but is more than half a tonne lighter, so the performance differential is not as wide as you might expect.
The ride can never be as relaxed, but from point to point on twisty roads the Aston would struggle to get away from it – for as long as it stayed in brakes.
Capris up to the 2.8i famously used the same solid discs on all models from 1600 to 3-litre; the vented items here are an improvement but remain only adequate, with a reassuringly firm pedal but no extra bite like the Aston when you push harder.
The Aston Martin V8 Vantage X-Pack’s body roll acts like a safety net to discourage over-enthusiastic driving
John’s car exhibits the usual Capri slight brake vibration even on light applications, and AP four-pots clasping bigger discs may be next on the menu.
So here’s the big question: which would you take home? The Capri does almost everything the Aston can at something like a sixth of the price.
It’s rarer yet easier to live with, especially in terms of maintenance costs.
As investments, fast Fords have been increasingly popular in the past couple of years, while Astons have struggled at auction, like almost everything else – but there has been some recent recovery.
The Aston Martin V8 Vantage X-Pack (closest) has the more attention-seeking styling
A straight fight between these two pinnacles of 1980s British rear-drive desirability is meaningless – any more than comparing Huntsman and Primark, only to establish that both make perfectly serviceable clothes.
The Aston goes about its business under a carefully distilled but constant air of old-world quality, while the Capri just does it like it says on the tin – with an added glint of menace.
It’s ironic that Ford would one day own Aston Martin, but these very individual fast coupés come from places of glorious divergence.
Images: Jayson Fong
Thanks to: Dylan Miles; Pearce’s Farmshop & Café
Factfiles
Aston Martin V8 Vantage X-Pack
- Sold/number built 1986-’89/137
- Construction steel chassis, aluminium outer panels over steel body frame
- Engine all-alloy, dohc-per-bank 5340cc V8, four Weber 48IDF carburettors
- Max power 400-432bhp @ 6200-6250rpm
- Max torque 390-395lb ft @ 5000-5100rpm
- Transmission five-speed manual, RWD via LSD
- Suspension: front independent, by double wishbones, anti-roll bar rear de Dion axle, four links, Watt linkage; coil springs, telescopic dampers f/r
- Steering power-assisted rack and pinion
- Brakes vented discs, inboard at rear, with twin servos
- Length 15ft 3¾in (4667mm)
- Width 6ft 2½in (1890mm)
- Height 4ft 4¼in (1327mm)
- Wheelbase 8ft 6¾in (2610mm)
- Weight 4012lb (1820kg)
- 0-60mph 5.2 secs
- Top speed 172mph
- Mpg 13.4
- Price new £87,000 (Vantage, 1988)
- Price now £250-350,000*
Ford Capri 3.0S X-Pack
- Sold/number built 1977-’80/c100
- Construction steel monocoque
- Engine all-iron, ohv 2994-3094cc V6, triple dual-choke 42DCNF Weber carburettors
- Max power 175bhp @ 5000rpm
- Max torque 194lb ft @ 4000rpm
- Transmission four-speed manual, RWD via LSD
- Suspension: front independent, by MacPherson struts, anti-roll bar rear live axle, single-leaf springs, staggered telescopic dampers
- Steering power-assisted rack and pinion
- Brakes ventilated discs front, drums rear, with servo
- Length 14ft 6¾in (4439mm)
- Width 6ft 1in (1854mm)
- Height 4ft 4in (1323mm)
- Wheelbase 8ft 5in (2565mm)
- Weight 2650lb (1202kg)
- 0-60mph 7.4 secs
- Top speed 132mph
- Mpg 22
- Price new £4594 (3.0S, 1978)
- Price now £35-60,000*
*Prices correct at date of original publication
Enjoy more of the world’s best classic car content every month when you subscribe to C&SC – get our latest deals here
READ MORE
Aston Martin DBS V8 vs Jensen Interceptor SP vs Gordon-Keeble GK1: British beef
Ford Capri 2.8 injection vs Renault Fuego Turbo vs Lancia HPE Volumex: a question of aspiration
Advantage Aston Martin: driving the V8 Vantage
Paul Hardiman
Paul Hardiman is a regular contributor to – and former Deputy Editor of – Classic & Sports Car