Add steering that is heavy and lacking in feel compared with the Charade, and VW’s Polo proves to be more of a point-and-shoot weapon than a true back-road blaster.
This VW Polo G40 has ‘Le Mans’ cloth trim
Both of these cars were well judged for their respective customer bases, however, even in their methods of forced induction.
Those coming to Volkswagen for a small hot hatch in 1990 were mainstream motorists who wanted not only speed, but also build quality and refinement – qualities that the many French, Italian, Japanese or British options lacked.
The G40 engine’s ability to behave just as if it were 500cc or so larger was perfect.
That same customer group was likely more concerned with straight-line performance than cornering G-forces and exit speeds.
The Volkswagen Polo G40’s plain dials
Daihatsu being such a niche brand – in virtually every market, not just the UK – meant the Charade GTti was always going to have a distinct and equally niche appeal; simply knowing what one was marked you out as an enthusiast, as it does today.
In everyday use the Daihatsu asks for compromises that the Volkswagen does not, whether because of its austere interior or its less relaxed cruising ability, but it is the more rewarding car for an involved driver on a twisty road.
Turbocharging was just part of a recipe that maximised bangs for the buck in the lightweight Charade.
The Daihatsu Charade GTti’s tight shutlines
Daihatsu was on the right track historically: small turbo motors became the engines of choice for hot hatches, while the sub-1-litre turbo ‘triple’ has been the supermini default for the past decade, including the VW Polo.
Not that it helped Daihatsu stay relevant in the European market.
The G-Lader approach ultimately proved less durable and less efficient than turbocharging, and VW moved to turbos in 1994.
It wasn’t a complete blind alley, though: Wolfsburg returned to superchargers for the excellent twin-charged 1.4 TSI in the Mk5 Polo GTI, but this would use a more traditional, Roots-type Eaton supercharger.
The VW Polo G40’s supercharged engine gives strong, big-car power delivery
Today, it is very difficult to pick between them.
The Volkswagen is definitely the collector’s choice, with its iconic styling and a stronger reputation.
It’s a more nostalgic drive for most, and more pleasant thanks to its relative comfort – plus, unlike some cars you’d buy for nostalgia, it has the performance to get out of its own way and have fun with.
But the Daihatsu feels like unearthing a hidden gem: it’s a cult classic.
The early-’90s era was the last hurrah of cars built this light; never again would we get such modern, powerful and compact powertrains stuffed into something so featherweight.
It’s a tin can strapped to a rocket, and it’s all the better for it.
Images: Jack Harrison
Factfiles
Volkswagen Polo G40
- Sold/number built 1989-’94/c5000
- Construction steel monocoque
- Engine iron-block, alloy-head, sohc 1272cc ‘four’, scroll-type supercharger, multi-point fuel injection
- Max power 113bhp @ 6000rpm
- Max torque 110lb ft @ 3600rpm
- Transmission five-speed manual, FWD
- Suspension: front independent, by MacPherson struts rear torsion beam, telescopic dampers; anti-roll bar f/r
- Steering rack and pinion
- Brakes discs front, drums rear, with servo
- Length 12ft 4in (3765mm)
- Width 5ft 3in (1590mm)
- Height 4ft 4in (1325mm)
- Wheelbase 7ft 8in (2335mm)
- Weight 1785lb (830kg)
- 0-60mph 8.6 secs
- Top speed 122mph
- Mpg 36
- Price new £11,568 (1991)
- Price now £6-20,000*
Daihatsu Charade GTti
- Sold/number built 1987-’93/227,000
- Construction steel monocoque
- Engine iron-block, alloy-head, dohc 993cc triple, IHI turbocharger, electronic fuel injection
- Max power 101bhp @ 6500rpm
- Max torque 96lb ft @ 3500rpm
- Transmission five-speed manual, FWD
- Suspension independent, by MacPherson struts, telescopic dampers, anti-roll bar f/r
- Steering rack and pinion
- Brakes discs, with servo
- Length 11ft 10in (3610mm)
- Width 5ft 4in (1615mm)
- Height 4ft 7in (1397mm)
- Wheelbase 7ft 8in (2340mm)
- Weight 1785lb (810kg)
- 0-60mph 8.2 secs
- Top speed 114mph
- Mpg 38
- Price new £9340 (1991)
- Price now £6-15,000*
*Prices correct at date of original publication
Enjoy more of the world’s best classic car content every month when you subscribe to C&SC – get our latest deals here
READ MORE
Volkswagen Golf at 50: Wolfsburg’s best vs rivals
History of turbocharging: the force awakens
Peugeot 205 Rallye vs Citroën AX GT: French featherweights
Charlie Calderwood
Charlie Calderwood is Classic & Sports Car’s Features Editor